7 Best Butt Plug Tails 2023

#1 Frisky Fox Tail Anal Plug

Reigning in position number one, the Frisky Fox Tail Anal Plug is the perfect toy that can bring out your inner exhibitionist. Just slip in the plug between the cheeks and twerk all you want for a sexy and seductive roleplay with your partner.

Our Experience

The Frisky Fox Tail is outrageously kinky and just the right length to arouse the interest of your partner. So if you have had some experience with butt plugs and want to take things up a notch, get your hands on this toy stat.

The plug is insertable up to 4 inches, which makes it suitable for both experts and new ‘comers’. And it has a T-shaped base for easy retrieval, so you can comfortably enjoy the session without compromising safety.

Also, we love the big, fluffy tail, which is about 14 inches long and looks very provocative when you swish from side to side. If you plan on answering your partner’s booty call, make sure to put this on before rocking his world. Or just wear it to surprise him, because he’ll surely appreciate this foxy number.

Pros:

• Flexible plug insertable up to 4-inches
• Suitable toy for beginners
• Features a T-shaped safety base for easy retrieval
• 14-inches long, high-quality faux fur tail

Cons:

• Color of the fur fades soon

Bottom Line

Our first entry deserves all the limelight as it can truly mesmerize the onlooker as you unleash the wild side. Butt plugs are great and all, but with this, you can double the fun and bring alive your naughtiest fantasies.

#2 Foxxxy Fox Tail Glass Anal Plug

All of us, at some point in time, thought what it would be like to have a tail. But the makers of the Foxxxy Fox Tail took things a ‘w’hole lot further and attached a luscious piece of fur to an exciting glass anal plug.

Our Experience

If we had to pen down a tagline for our second item, it would probably be “insert for fun.” As that’s pretty much all you gotta do, to turn up the heat in the bedroom. To begin with, we love this wicked toy with a 4-inch insertable length that you can use to heighten the sensations during foreplay.

The long, bushy 9-inch tail with stripes is perfect for turning on your partner while you engage in some hot booty action. But the games don’t end here as the glass anal plug can be heated or cooled in a bowl of water for some naughty temperature play.

You can get off using the slick glass surface and pleasure yourself with a little teasing, massage, and even penetration. All the while, you can have your partner watching as the tail grazes across your rear when pulling some seductive moves.

Pros:

• 4-inch insertable length for ultimate pleasure
• Soft, bushy fox tail with striped pattern
• Ideal for naughty games and roleplay
• Glass anal plug is perfect for temperature play

Cons:

• Tail is a tad difficult to clean

Bottom Line

The Foxxxy Fox Tail is a treat to watch and oh-so-tantalizing with all that bushy chaos of fur. So, just put it on and give him a show he’ll not forget any time soon. And when performing, don’t forget to show yourself a good time.

#3 Unicorn Tail Butt Plug

Unicorns may not exist, but their tails sure do! And it’s not like you’ve to visit a wish-granting factory for one, as the Unicorn Tail Butt Plug is among the most popular sex toys online. So, if you’re looking for something cute yet saucy, we recommend buying this colorful piece.

Our Experience

We all love some backdoor action now and then, but why not pull out all the stops and add a tail in the mix. That being said, we’re very impressed with the Unicorn Tail, as it can bring more adventure to the bang-a-thon, with the gorgeous, flowy pink tail.

What impressed us the most is the body-safe silicone anal plug that helps you climax with a heady rush. If you’re interested in kinky cosplay, this is the perfect fit for the job, thanks to the alluringly long tail.

Plus, the plug has an insertable length of 3.5 inches, so you can train your bottom with this toy if you’ve not experienced anal penetration before. Just get your partner on board for a horny session, with this bright little plaything, and keep wagging for satisfying climaxes.

Pros:

• Ideal for cosplay sessions
• Gorgeous, flowing pink tail perfect for visual stimulation
• 5-inch insertable length suitable for beginners
• Plug made with body-safe and luxuriously smooth silicone

Cons:

• Slightly on the expensive side

Bottom Line

We are delighted with this cheeky, little toy that can get temperatures soaring in the bedroom. If you’ve not tried something risque for a while and need some inspiration, we suggest walking out with this on to dazzle your partner after a long and boring day.

#4 Tailz Bunny Tail Anal Plug

You may not be a Playboy model, but that shouldn’t stop you from becoming a cute and naughty bunny. So, just get yourself the Tailz Bunny Tail Anal Plug and complete the look with lacy white lingerie, and he’ll owe you one for life.

Our Experience

Who knew that butt plugs could be more fun with a tail?

And not just a random animal resemblance, our fourth item is a beautiful plaything featuring a soft, velvety rabbit tail.

We’re thrilled about this petite toy, which provides enough flexibility for you to prance around comfortably. Plus, unlike the other longish tails, you can actually wear this during intercourse and enjoy the best of both worlds.

The plug is ergonomically designed with a tapered tip and flared base, so you relish the full and deep sensation without accidentally getting hurt. Meanwhile, the plume of feathers, sprouting from your butt, tempts your partner to go all guns blazing. With an insertable length of 2.5 inches, this anal toy sure checks all the boxes and spices up the encounters in bed.

Pros:

• Features a soft, velvety plume of feathers
• Flexible and comfortable to wear during intercourse
• 5-inches insertable for a full and deep sensation
• Simple and easy to use with lube

Cons:

• The feathers are a little sparse

Bottom Line

All in all, we’re very impressed with this neat package and suggest buying it for a fun session with your partner. Also, it’s pretty simple and easy to use with lube, so you won’t need much time getting used to backdoor pecking.

#5 Mink Tail Butt Plug

Animal fantasies involve a lot of things, but a butt plug tail is undoubtedly the sauciest among them. Now that we’ve covered rabbits, foxes and unicorns, take a look at our fifth option – the Mink Tail Butt Plug, designed to titillate.

Our Experience

If your partner has relayed his fantasies of seeing you in an animal costume, it’s time you ‘plugged’ in this bad boy for a naughty petting session. Unlike other butt plugs, this toy is metallic, which makes it very smooth and easy to insert.

Also, you’ll love the sensual feeling of the tail grazing against your skin, while your partner enjoys the show. If you have not really warmed up to butt play but are keen on experimenting, then let’s just say this is the perfect choice for beginners.

Just bring alive the performer in you and add some pizazz to good, ol’ vanilla with this luxuriously long tail plug. And the best part is that it’s compatible with all types of lubricants, meaning you can use anything comfortable and shake that thick butt for some serious seduction.

Pros:

• Easy to insert, smooth metallic plug
• Compatible with all types of lubricants
• Perfect toy for beginners
• Plug is non-porous and phthalate-free

Cons:

• Product is relatively expensive

Bottom Line

We like that the plug is made of aluminum, and also non-porous and phthalate-free, which makes it super easy to clean after play. Therefore, if you need a low maintenance toy for total anal ecstasy, we suggest buying this product.

#6 Tailz Bad Kitty Silicone Cat Tail Anal Plug

Catwoman is easily one of the most iconic comic book characters of our times, and nothing is sexier than a cat costume for some steamy roleplay under the sheets. You can count on your ‘dark knight’ to rise, all you gotta do is wag the Bad Kitty Silicone Cat Tail.

Our Experience

We are fans of the Bad Kitty Anal Plug that can perfectly portray your feline charm with the long, luscious black tail. First things first, we like the smooth silicone plug attached to the top of the tail, which is safe for extended wear, thanks to the hypoallergenic material.

Furthermore, the spade-shaped shaft has an insertable length of 4 inches, ideal for experts in anal masturbation. So, if you’re in the mood to push your boundaries, we suggest getting this toy for unrestrained pleasure.

Also, we like the two handy loops at the base that let you turn up the heat by connecting a bullet vibrator to the plug. You can enjoy sinful buzzing on the rear and swish the super soft 2 ft long tail for the ultimate naughty kitty cosplay.

Pros:

• Plug is made with silicone, hypoallergenic material
• 2 ft long, black tail perfect for cosplay ideas
• 4-inch insertable length for a full and deep sensation
• Plug can be fitted with a bullet vibrator on the base

Cons:

• Not suitable for beginners

Bottom Line

We find the bendy, black plug tail quite fun and flirty and recommend buying it for super long sessions. Plus, the plug is phthalate-free, and non-porous so you can ride all you want without compromising on safety or comfort.

#7 Tailz Grey Fox Tail Anal Plug

If you thought we’ve run out of ‘foxy’ options, take a look at our seventh and final pick – Tailz Grey Fox Tail Anal Plug. Unleash your wild side, and we’re sure your partner will enjoy the amorous advances you make with this nifty sex toy in the right place.

Our Experience

Honestly, it’s a visual treat to watch this bushy tail as you walk around with panache. You could get into an elaborate costume, pair it with lingerie, or even just wear the plug, and we’re sure it’ll look delightfully sexy.

The plug itself is semi-flexible with an ample insertable length of 4 inches. So, if you’re in an insatiable mood, just go to town with this wicked little toy. Furthermore, the plug features a tapered design with an accommodating neck for superior comfort from the get-go.

Together with the 14-inch long, fluffy tail, this plaything can really set the stage for erotic foreplay and lots of teasing. Therefore, if you’re looking to add visual stimulation in the mix, we suggest getting your hands on this one for some memorable and passionate encounters.

Pros:

• Ample insertable length of 4-inches
• Plug has a tapered design with an accommodating neck
• 14-inches long fluffy tail perfect for sexy encounters
• Adds visual stimulation during foreplay

Cons:

• Tail is difficult to clean

Bottom Line

Nothing is more alluring and flirtatious than a foxtail on a bootylicious woman. You may have tried experimenting with other toys, and even if you have not, give this one a shot since you can pleasure yourself and also put up a show.

Final thoughts about the best Butt Plug Tails

That’s all, folks!

We hope you could find the most rewarding and satisfying fit from among our all-star selection.

However, before we leave, here’s a piece of advice.

Do not forget to lube up (our anal lube guide) the anal plug before inserting and always clean up the toy after use.

If you want some vibrations then head over and find the best vibrating butt plug and get the vibes going or take a look at our ultimate guide to butt plugs.

Till next time, stay wild!